In the arena of digital-input devices, the mechanical keyboard occupies a niche yet passionate segment of marketplace. This piece of hardware boasts a firm and tactile response when typing, offering satisfying “clicks” not available with their membrane-based counterparts: all characteristics contributing to the consistent popularity among tech-enthusiasts. But, one discreetly divisive aspect to notice about these tactile luxuries is the noise. The heralded “click-clack” can create a dichotomy of sensations – a rhythmic charm to some but an irritable cacophony to others. This article explores the science behind mechanical keyboard dampening, offering a beginner’s guide on how to achieve the tactile satisfaction, sans the sound storm.
Keyboards function through ‘switches’. These are tactically positioned beneath each key, sending signals to the computer when they are pressed – a simple enough concept to understand. However, the mechanical keyboard’s ‘switches’ are vastly different from the ones found in its silicone-based siblings. These ‘switches’ in mechanical keyboards employ a physical, mechanical mechanism, spring-loaded for each keypress. The individual nature of these ‘switches’ is what provides the unmistakably precise tactile response – and the associated acoustic feedback.
Noise creation in these keyboards happens due to the hard plastic stem in the ‘switch’ mechanism. When a key is pressed, the stem slides downwards, causing the spring to compress. Upon reaching the bottom, the stem hits the keyboard’s housing, creating the first sound. The second emerges when the key is released, causing the spring to decompress and shoot the stem back upwards. This rapid ascension ends with the stem slamming into the top of the keyboard’s casing, causing that second cacophonous echo.
Dampening, effectively, is the process of reducing the aforementioned noise. There are several commonly-explored methodologies to achieve this. The spectrum of options ranges from simple solutions, such as placing a desk mat under the keyboard to absorb shocks, to more complex ones like acquiring specialized ‘quiet’ switches.
Silent or quiet switches are the most straightforward solution. These switches are uniquely engineered to be quieter than stock alternatives. Their design entails a rubber piece embedded into the stem to dampen the sound it produces on impact. Cherry MX Silent Red and Black switches are popular examples. However, a potential downside to this method is that the inclusion of rubber can marginally alter the typing feel.
O-rings are a highly cost-effective solution without having to manipulate the individual switch. These small silicon rings are added to the keycap stem, dampening the sound resulting from the bottoming out of the stem. However, similar to Silent Switches, some users report a minor change in the typing feel.
Switch films, although less directly linked to noise reduction, help decrease the overall wobble of keycaps, resulting in less rattle. These films are thin plastic or rubber pieces placed between the switch top and bottom halves, thus stabilizing their movement.
Another popular method to achieve noise reduction is through Lube. Lubricating the switches can minimize the noise caused by friction between moving parts. This process requires careful application of the lube to the stem and spring and can significantly dampen the sound, in addition to producing a smoother keystroke.
The most complex yet effective method is Foam padding or case lining. This process involves lining the keyboard’s inside with a foam layer. Approved forms of foam include EVA, neoprene, or sorbothane – each designed to absorb sound. The padding prevents the internal echoes resulting from typing, thus reducing the overall noise level.
Mechanical Keyboard Dampening is an auditory art and science, hingeing on mitigating noise and highly customizable accounting for individual acoustic preferences. While these methods can prove effective, they can also bribe a change in the typing feel, pose varying degrees of installation complexity, and cause shifts in cost. Although silence may be golden, it’s important to remember not to lose the joyful click-and-clack that drew you to the world of mechanical keyboards in the first place. The science of silence is all about striking the right balance: a veritable symphony of subtlety and satisfaction.